The Subway Stopped in the Tunnel During the Hurricane. Then the Water Started Coming Through the Doors
A NYC subway flood during a hurricane: commuters trapped in a tunnel watched water pour through the doors, then discovered the tunnel outside was completely full.
On this page
Aisha Grant, 28, had just finished a twelve-hour shift as an ER nurse in Lower Manhattan when the hurricane warnings turned into a city-wide emergency. She caught one of the last trains heading toward Brooklyn, soaked from the walk to the station, and squeezed into a crowded car with her rain jacket still dripping. Twenty minutes later, she was holding her phone above rising water in a pitch-black tunnel, filming what she thought might be her last video.
The Train Stopped
The car was full of exhausted commuters: office workers, students, a construction crew, an elderly woman with a cane. Everyone was quiet, tired, scrolling their phones. Somewhere under the East River, the train slowed, shuddered, and stopped. The conductor announced a “brief signal delay.”
Then the train jolted, hard, like something had hit it.
Water Through the Doors
On Aisha’s video, the first thing you see is brown water bursting through the rubber gaps in the sliding doors. Not a trickle. Jets of it, spraying across the floor. Within seconds, the water was up to everyone’s ankles and rising.
People jumped onto the seats. A man in a gray suit, Victor, in his fifties, waded to the doors and tried to pry them apart with his hands. In the corner, an elderly woman named Mrs. Lee, in her eighties, was stuck in her seat, unable to climb up, as the water crept toward her knees.
The Lights Went Out
Then the fluorescent lights flickered and died. The train’s hum faded to silence. For a moment, the only sound was rushing water and people screaming. Then phone flashlights started snapping on, one after another, throwing wild beams of light across the car.
Aisha’s nurse training took over. She waded to Mrs. Lee, and together with a young man in a hoodie, she lifted the old woman up onto the seat. Mrs. Lee clutched her cane and began to pray.
"The Tunnel's Full!"
Victor was still fighting with the doors. With a final heave, he forced them open a few inches. Instead of escaping air, a torrent of water exploded into the car, knocking him backward.
In the flashlight beams, everyone saw it at the same time. The tunnel outside the train was completely full of water. Not partly flooded. Full, from the tracks to the ceiling, pressing against the car.
“It’s full!” Victor yelled. “The tunnel’s full!”
Aisha’s video ends there.
The Air Pocket
What saved them was the design of the old subway car itself. The doors were forced shut again by the pressure, and the car’s sealed body trapped a pocket of air. Water kept seeping in, but slowly. Forty-one people stood on seats in the dark, breathing that air, for nearly two hours.
Aisha kept everyone calm. She organized people to take turns holding up Mrs. Lee, checked on a man with asthma, and told jokes to a group of frightened college students. Victor, it turned out, was a retired transit engineer. He knew that pumps would be running and that the water would eventually drain toward the lower sections of the tunnel.
The Rescue
Around two in the morning, the water began to drop. By three, it was below the windows. Emergency crews in dry suits waded through the tunnel with flood lights and led the passengers, one by one, along the tracks to an emergency exit. Mrs. Lee was carried out on a firefighter’s back, still holding her cane.
Every single passenger survived.
What Survivors Remember Most
Many of the passengers later said the darkness was worse than the water. Phone batteries started dying after the first hour, so Aisha asked everyone to turn their flashlights off and use only one at a time, passing a single light around the car. One of the college students started singing to keep people’s spirits up, and by the end, half the car was singing along, standing on the seats with water at their shins.
Victor said the hardest moment came when the water briefly rose again after a pump failed. “People went silent,” he said. “You could hear everyone counting the inches.” It dropped again ten minutes later, and somebody started clapping.
After the Storm
The flooding of subway tunnels during major storms is a real and serious danger in New York City. After past hurricanes, transit officials have spent years and billions of dollars on flood barriers and pumps. Aisha’s video has since been shared widely as a reminder of why people should avoid underground transit when a storm is hitting.
Aisha went back to work two days later. Mrs. Lee’s family found her through social media and invited her to Sunday dinner. “She told me she prayed the whole time,” Aisha said, “and that I was the answer. I told her I was just a nurse who happened to be on the wrong train.”
