He Thought a Big Walleye Hit His Line on Lake Superior. Then a Giant Eye Filled the Whole Ice Hole
An ice fisherman on Lake Superior had his rod ripped into the hole. Then a huge eye filled the circle and blinked, and cracks raced toward their boots.
On this page
Every winter, Dale and his wife drag their little ice shanty out onto frozen Lake Superior. He is in his fifties, wears the same camo bibs and fur trapper hat every year, and he lives for those long, quiet afternoons kneeling over an auger hole with a jig rod. His wife mostly comes for the company, the propane heater and the thermos of coffee. She started filming that afternoon only because Dale said he had a big one on.
The Rod Goes Down
Inside the shanty, the heater glows orange and both of their breaths fog in the air. Dale is kneeling over the hole, which is about eight inches across, black water inside a ring of white ice.
Without warning, his rod is ripped straight down into the hole. Dale does not let go, and his arm plunges into the freezing water up to the elbow. He yells. The rod is gone.
He pulls his arm free, gasping and laughing at the same time, the nervous kind of laugh people make when they are not sure yet whether they should be scared. “Must have been a monster walleye,” he says. His sleeve is soaked and steaming in the warm air of the shanty.
The Breath
Then the water in the hole starts to move.
It sloshes, gently at first, then it rises. It comes up over the edge of the hole and spreads across the ice around Dale’s knees in a thin sheet. And then, slowly, it drains back down into the hole, all of it, like something underneath had breathed out and then breathed back in.
Dale stops laughing. The only sounds are the wind pushing against the plywood walls of the shanty and the steady hiss of the propane.
The Eye
Something dark slides under the hole.
For a second the water goes completely black, darker than it should be even under the ice. Then the circle fills with something wet and glossy, pressed up against the bottom of the opening. It takes a moment to understand what you are looking at.
It is an eye. A single huge eye, so large that it fills the entire eight-inch hole edge to edge, with no white showing, only a dark wet iris.
And it blinks.
At that exact moment, the ice under them creaks. Long, deep groans run out through the lake in every direction, the booming sound that ice fishermen know means pressure is shifting somewhere below.
The Cracks
Thin white cracks begin to spread out from the edge of the hole, spidering across the ice floor of the shanty toward their boots. Dale does not stand up fast. He reaches back without looking away from the hole and takes his wife’s hand.
His voice drops to a whisper: “Get to the truck. Don’t run.”
The video ends there.
What Happened Next
They did exactly what he said. His wife later explained that Dale had heard old-timers say for years that you never run on cracking ice, because pounding feet only make it worse. They backed out of the shanty, walked carefully to their pickup truck about fifty yards away, and drove slowly toward shore without once looking back.
Neither of them went back out that weekend. When Dale returned four days later with his brother-in-law, the shanty was still standing, but it had shifted almost six feet from where they had set it up. The hole Dale had drilled was gone. In its place was a much larger opening, several feet wide, already refrozen into a perfectly round circle of clear ice.
Under that clear ice, his brother-in-law swore he could see Dale’s jig rod, still hanging straight down in the dark water, the line pulled tight toward the bottom.
The Lake That Keeps Its Secrets
Lake Superior is the largest freshwater lake in the world by surface area and more than thirteen hundred feet deep at its deepest point. Locals have told stories about it for as long as people have lived along its shores. Most of those stories are easy to laugh off in the summer. They are a lot harder to laugh off sitting in a small shanty in the middle of the ice, listening to it groan.
Dale still ice fishes. He has a new shanty and a new rod. But his wife says he has changed one habit: he never drills his hole in the same spot twice, and before he drops a line he always kneels down and looks into the water for a long, quiet moment first.
Other fishermen on that part of the lake have started telling their own stories since the video spread: rods yanked down without a bite, holes that slosh on windless days, and one man who swears he heard something knock twice on the ice right under his chair. Most of them laugh when they tell it. Most of them also moved their shanties closer to shore this year.
